Ugly Soap – $5 Surprise Bar

Same great soap. Slightly questionable looks. Only $5.

Sometimes a color doesn't turn out quite right. Sometimes a swirl has a mind of its own. And sometimes a perfectly good bar of soap is just… ugly.

We're not throwing it away.

Every Ugly Soap bar is made with the same 100% raw goat milk from our own goats, grass-fed beef tallow, oils and butters as our regular bars. It has the same rich, creamy lather and the same handcrafted formula—the only thing that didn't make the cut is the appearance.

And at just $5 for a full-size bar, it's one of the best deals on the site.

The Fun Part? It's a Surprise.

You'll receive one randomly selected full-size bar from one of our recent batches. Your bar could be fruity, fresh, cozy, clean, tropical, woodsy, floral—or something completely different.

You won't know which one you're getting until it arrives.

No choosing scents. No choosing designs. That's part of the fun.

Why You'll Love It

• Just $5 for a full-size bar

• 100% raw goat milk from our own goats

• Made with grass-fed beef tallow

• Same rich, creamy lather as our regular bars

• Great way to try a scent you might not normally choose

• Every bar is a surprise

• Perfect little add-on to your order

• An easy way to get closer to free shipping at $35+

Scent: Surprise! Varies by bar
Smells like: Could be fruity, fresh, cozy, clean, tropical, floral & more
Size: Approx. 4–4.5 oz

Ingredients

Ingredients vary by bar. All bars are made with our goat milk and tallow soap base, which includes raw goat milk, grass-fed beef tallow, coconut oil, palm oil, avocado oil, sunflower oil, shea butter, castor oil, and sodium hydroxide (used in saponification). Individual bars may also contain fragrance or essential oils, mica, and other additives depending on the batch.

Free U.S. shipping on orders $35+

Please note: Ugly Soap bars are discounted for cosmetic imperfections and are randomly selected. Scents and designs cannot be requested. All sales are final.