Made the Nice List – Holiday Goat Milk & Tallow Soap Gift Set

For the ones who actually made the nice list.

Need an easy holiday gift that feels thoughtful, looks adorable, and is actually something they’ll use? Made the Nice List is a ready-to-gift holiday set with two full-size Goat Milk & Tallow Soaps plus a few extras to make their shower a little better.

Every gift set includes one full-size The G.O.A.T. Unscented Goat Milk & Tallow Soap plus one full-size scented soap based on the scent style you choose.

Each set also includes a soap saver and wooden soap tray, all bundled together with festive holiday ribbon and our Made the Nice List gift tag.

And because a cute gift should still be a good gift, every soap is handcrafted with 100% raw goat milk from our own goats, never powdered and never diluted with water, and grass-fed beef tallow for the rich, thick, creamy lather The Sour Goat is known for.

Perfect for teachers, coworkers, neighbors, Secret Santa, hostess gifts, friends, family, or those last-minute “oh crap, I forgot someone” gifts.

Choose Your Scent Style

Please read before ordering: Every gift set already includes one The G.O.A.T. Unscented Soap. Your scent selection is for the second bar only.

When you choose a scent style, you are choosing the type of scent you want, not the exact soap. I will personally choose one available full-size soap that fits the scent style you select.

Fresh & Clean – I’ll choose one available soap with a fresh, crisp, clean-smelling scent.

Tropical & Fruity – I’ll choose one available soap with a tropical, fruity, beachy, or bright scent.

Warm & Cozy – I’ll choose one available soap with a warm, sweet, rich, or cozy scent.

Essential Oils – I’ll choose one available soap scented with essential oils.

Surprise Me! – Leave it completely up to me. I’ll choose one available scented soap that I think makes a great pairing with The G.O.A.T.

Want a specific scented soap? Select “I’ll Email My Scent Choice” when ordering, then email me at Kimberly@thesourgoat.com with your order number and the one scented soap you would like included.

Specific scent requests are subject to availability. If your requested soap is unavailable, I’ll contact you so we can choose another.

What’s Included

• 1 Full-Size The G.O.A.T. Unscented Goat Milk & Tallow Soap
• 1 Full-Size Scented Goat Milk & Tallow Soap
• 1 Soap Saver
• 1 Wooden Soap Tray
• Festive holiday ribbon and Made the Nice List gift tag
• Ready to give, no wrapping required

Why You’ll Love It

• Includes our signature The G.O.A.T. Unscented Soap
• Choose the scent style for the second bar
• Made with 100% raw goat milk from our own goats
• Made with grass-fed beef tallow
• Rich, thick, creamy lather
• Handcrafted in small batches
• Festively packaged and ready to gift
• An easy, useful holiday gift that still feels personal

Soap Ingredients

Beef Tallow, Raw Goat Milk, Palm Oil, Coconut Oil, Avocado Oil, High Oleic Sunflower Oil, Shea Butter, Castor Oil, Sodium Hydroxide, Fragrance and/or Essential Oil, Colorants*

*Ingredients and colorants vary depending on the scented soap included in your gift set.

Real ingredients. Real soap. Real difference.

Free U.S. shipping on orders $35+